Homemade shortbread cookies are already a favorite of mine- buttery, flaky, delicious, and… dangerous!
But then top them with this pretty lemony glaze that gives a pleasant little tartness, and my oh my! They become ‘to-die-for’!
Homemade shortbread cookies are already a favorite of mine- buttery, flaky, delicious, and… dangerous!
But then top them with this pretty lemony glaze that gives a pleasant little tartness, and my oh my! They become ‘to-die-for’!
Yes, the cookie with the most names. Many know it as the Preacher Cookie, we called them Fudgies when I was growing up, some people call them No-Bake cookies, and my husband always called them Chocolate Oats– which is the name that has stuck with my family.
These are probably one of his very favorite things to eat ever- and my kids are right behind him. In fact, they “Chocolate-Oat” me to death! How about some variety, people? Nope- these are what they want.
So, seeing as I make these so frequently, I have discovered some tips that make these no-bake treats absolutely perfect.
Now, I know there are many different preferences when it comes to this popular cookie. But, I have found many versions end up sticky, or dry, or do not set properly.
In my world, the perfect Preacher Cookie will be:
So- here are some tips.
Sugar and Spice and Everything Nice~ that could describe the classic Snickerdoodle cookie! They’re rolled in ‘sugar and spice’ (cinnamon sugar), they have a delicate flavor, they’re soft, and they have been baking into cute little round cookies in people’s kitchens for years now. I would say that is a pretty nice cookie!
I’ve seen many recent versions of this cookie that have been dressed up, adding this and that in an effort, I guess, to make an old recipe new again. But I like old recipes!!
So, in an effort to keep the simple and basic alive and well, I share with you my go-to version for Snickerdoodles.
Coating:
In a mixing bowl, beat the butter, sugar, and eggs until fluffy.
Add in the dry ingredients. Mix well.
In a small bowl, combine the cinnamon and sugar.
Roll the dough into balls- (approx. a heaping Tbs of dough at a time is what I do)
Roll the balls in the cinnamon sugar and place on an ungreased cookie sheet.
Bake at 400 for 8-9 minutes. They should be puffy and still look a little soft. (over-baking will make these dry)
Remove from the oven and allow to sit for a minute to set.
Remove to a wire rack.
My name is Kari. I am wife to Tim, "Mama" to 4, and I'm a Christian- saved by grace.
I love old things, simple country living, farmhouse style, music from the 30s and 40s, old-fashioned skills, and gardening! My husband and I enjoy learning to grow more of our own food, raise chickens and a few cows and pigs for fresh beef and pork.
And, of course, I love to cook and bake! Serving delicious homemade food to my family and friends is something I enjoy very much.
My style is simple, comforting food done well, that is family-friendly, using more and more "real" foods.